Sunday, Jul 21st

Last update05:20:13 AM GMT

You are here News Domestic (USA) In Property Rights Case, Justices Sharply Debate Power of Precedent

In Property Rights Case, Justices Sharply Debate Power of Precedent

E-mail Print PDF
SCOTUS rules in property rights caseOverturning a 1985 precedent, the Supreme Court on Friday ruled that plaintiffs may sue in federal court to seek compensation as soon as state and local governments take their property through eminent domain. The earlier ruling had required plaintiffs to sue in state court.

The vote was 5 to 4, with the court’s more conservative justices in the majority. The decision was notable for an exchange about the court’s attitude toward precedent.

Writing for the majority, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. said overruling the 1985 decision was justified because it “was not just wrong.

“Its reasoning was exceptionally ill founded,” he wrote. He added that the decision had “come in for repeated criticism over the years from justices of this court and many respected commentators.”


Most Recent Related Stories...

Virginia Democrats vow to boycott event if Trump attends, invoke 'send her back' chants

Jamestown event: Dems to boycott if Trump attends Democrats in Virginia's state legislature are vowing to boycott a ceremony in Jamestown later this month...

Jeffrey Epstein denied bail, must remain behind bars until sex trafficking trial

Epstein denied bailA New York federal judge on Thursday ordered Jeffrey Epstein held without bail, siding with prosecutors...

Private investigator has spent a decade on Jeffrey Epstein's trail

Investigator spent a decade following EpstienWhen Detective Michael Fisten hung up his badge after 30 years in law enforcement and started...

It will be 90 degrees or warmer for nearly 90% of Americans this week

Global warming affects 90% of AmericansTens of millions of Americans will swelter through the hottest weather of the summer over the next...
America's # 1 Enemy
Tee Shirt
& Help Support!
TVNL Tee Shirt
Conserve our Planet
& Help Support!
Get your 9/11 & Media
Deception Dollars
& Help Support!
The Loaded Deck
The First & the Best!
The Media & Bush Admin Exposed!